1. DEATH PENALITY NEEDED ASAP FOR THIS TRAITOR !!!!
|
|
2. Must be related to Ulmert!
|
|
3. sounds like an israeli muslim
i could be wrong, but not likely.
| mike , |
israel (formerly usa |
|
(11.23.07) |
|
|
4. HEY, EFRAT................................................
NOT A DAMN THING WRONG,WITH THE "STRUCTURE OF THIS ARTICLE !
O.K.-ONE MORE TIME AND,YOU'VE ASSURED YOURSELF A PLACE IN THE WORLD TO COME !
KOLAKAVOD !
| AVROHOM BILGREI , |
ZION |
|
(11.23.07) |
|
|
5. NOTHING NEW....................
Dubious characters exist in all countries.One Iranian giving statements to the press in USA created a big issue.all the Western media covered that traitor.Now,what about this guy?
| MAHMOOD , |
LONDON-UK |
|
(11.23.07) |
|
|
6. it is true believe me
when i was allowed to go to israil i was a patient of this psychiator he tried to fix my head believe me but he didnt do a good job
now i can see that i drove him mad instead
thank you for helping us wallahe doctor shukran
thank you please ynet
| rashid , |
palistinian |
|
(11.23.07) |
|
|
7. #3, yeah David Shamir is a well-known arab name
He is just a greedy Israeli like Tannumbaum.
|
|
8. IF A DEATH sentence is handed down, I will....
....supply the court with the bullet so they don't have to pay a single shekle on this pile of zevel.
| j , |
jerusalem, israel |
|
(11.23.07) |
|
|
9. Wouldn't be surprised that the Peace Now organization
are spies for P.A. This anti-Israel group are capable of anything.
| Joseph P. , |
Jerusalem |
|
(11.23.07) |
|
|
10. Spy
This Dr. is either a member of Peace now, Yesh g'vul or an Arab plenty of arab Doctors in Israel.
| Rod , |
Fargo N. Dakota |
|
(11.23.07) |
|
|
11. #3 You make a great statement...
Major tried to spy for Iran. Shin Bet arrests Israeli reserve major David Shamir...
You must be thinking of Mohammed David Shamir...his cousin. LOL
Nice you can show your true prejudice colors...true blue and white!!!
| Elokim , |
Israel |
|
(11.23.07) |
|
|
12. People often go into careers in psychiatry or psychology...
because they are mentally ill. Of all healthcare professionals, psychiatrists have the highest suicide rate. So it is not surprising to me that a psychiatrist would flip out and think of betraying Israel for money from Moslems. I got a clue on how corrupt psychiatrists were long ago when my oldest sister Rachel had a nervous breakdown. When she told her psychiatrist she wanted to get a job because she felt that she was recovering, he told her that if she did, he would accuse her of faking her illness and have her prosecuted. He did not want his rice-bowl broken. Actress Barbara Streisand went to a psychiatrist at great expense for 14 years. When she did not feel any better after that time, she stopped going and said seeing a psychiatrist was a useless waste of time. Lawyers have told met privately that in their experience, it is the psychiatrists and psychologists that need mental help. For this doctor to want to sell out Israel for money from Moslems is lunacy.
|
|
13. 7, 11 - was i wrong?
so what this guy did DOESN'T sound like a muslim? unless i'm wrong, i do believe there is plenty of precedent for making the assumption.
and i suppose it's racist to assume that a suicide bomber is muslim, too? i'll bet neither of you do that.
| mike , |
israel (formerly usa |
|
(11.23.07) |
|
|
14. Manics build castles in air -psychiatrists collect the rent
|
|
15. the IDF
its good to know our army is doing its job so well...whos going to hand out all those exemptions to all of those draft dodgers now?
|
|
16. #13, it may not be racist but it certainly is stupid
When the person in question is called David Shamir, one should not leap to the assumption he is an Israeli arab.
As for suicide bombers, depends where there are... The world pioneers were the Tamil Tigers. I might make the assumption in Baghdad but not in Colombo.
Unfortunatel, there is also plenty of precedents for my fellow Israelis who have sold their country out.
|
|
17. I dont believe it Rivkahle #11 just dont believe it
You wrote a whole talkback without mentioning the bible even once? is it possible Rivkahle? not quoting even one pasuk from the bible?
Oy Rivkahle, I hope you are well and that it is just a little slipup on your part
You are still talking rubbish though
|
|
18. muslim assumption
the assumption that the spy is a muslim it reasonable since no where in this article is his name mentioned and anyone with common sense would assume a muslim more likely to spy against the jewish state than a jew. It is the fact that this spy is a jew that makes the story newsworthy and shocking.
| Kapara al Haismuk |
|
|
(11.23.07) |
|
|
19. He is not the only one
I am sure that hundreds more are already succeeded and more to follow. Cash for information? Sure why not.
| Wise Man , |
USA |
|
(11.23.07) |
|
|
20. 16 - the original article made no reference to anything
it just said an "israeli officer" and, being an overly politically correct publication, everyone was left to wonder and speculate. it was a safe bet, even with he wiggle room i left myself.
| mike , |
israel (formerly usa |
|
(11.23.07) |
|
|
21. IDF Psychiatrist
I read Debka file before this article. Debka named the spy.
However, because anyone could assume any name, the name is limited, very limited when used as a measure for one's motivation or political leanings. There is A LOT more to this story, besides the spy's name, rank and position. This guy was definitely pissed off about something.
| James Bond , |
London |
|
(11.23.07) |
|
|
22. Jewish dirty rat
When you stole the others land why not sell it out to make some cash or bottle of Vodka?
This is funny that Iran rejected him for his informations. This sounds to me there would be a spy fair going on in that sh1t land.
|
|
23. #3. I did not know the US
sends garbage to Israel. I'm glad it's true in your case.
|
|
24. #20 and jumping to conclusions
Just shows - you immediately jump to a conclusion "the bad guy must be a Moslem", you are then shown to be wrong, and you still seem to think that you had made an amusing little comment rather than a deeply racist and offensive accusation.
I'm surprised, myself, that the spy was not your wife - after all she is a Moslem, and that must mean, according to your truly perverted logic, that she has spy and traitor blood in her.
| English guy , |
London |
|
(11.23.07) |
|
|
25. 19: The reason it is llunacy for a Jew to sell information
to Moslems for money is that the Jew is almost certain to be betrayed or killed so a Moslem can go to Moslem heaven or brag to his/her friends that lying to an enemy is not lying in the religion of Islam
|
|
26. 17: Psychiatry and psychology are the antithesis of religion
Scientology is an offshoot of psychiatry and psychology if you real L. Ron Hubbard's first book, "Dianetics", which is what Scientology was called before it became a religion to get a tax exception writeoff. Much of psychology is based on the Greek myths which were good illustrations of human nature without the God of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob. Toward his death, Sigmund Freud, the father of modern psychiatry/psychology said if he had his life to live over, he would have devoted it to the study of supernatural phenomenon. I think at that point he was getting closer to a consciousness of God and of miracles of faith, but he died and went to hell as an unbeliever in the God of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob. Psychiatrists and psychologists want to replace God in a person's life. Much of what is done to people in mental hospitals is harmful. I have rarely seen a person come out of one well or even better. They come out subdued and sedated and oft raped by staff and other patients, whether male or female. My sister Rachel was raped so many times at the Arizona State Hospital while sedated so she could not defend herself from attacks by staff that she was sent to California many times for abortions while a patient at the Arizona State Hospital. The pregnancies came from her being raped. California has resolved the vaginal rape of mental patients at State and County mental lockdown facilities by DNA testing to find out who the rapists are. So now the rapists rape the mental patients in the anus, whether a female or male patient, heavily sedated. A school teacher named Patsy Willis had a nervous breakdown in Hanford, California, and that is what she said happened to her; but no one cared. White semen dripped from her anus when she went to the bathroom after waking up from sedation. So you think people get better at mental hospitals and psychiatrists and psycologists are a help for people? It is a racket. Even the prescription medicines given to mental patients often make the person worse. Read a few books on the connection of SSRI drugs like Prozac and suicide and school shootings and other murders. The SSRI drugs cause a worse psychosis than the patient had without taking them. BUT, taking prescription medicines that make a person worse rather than better makes MONEY for Big Pharma. May you perish in a mental lockdown facility to learn what truth is by experience since you do not listen to warnings.
|
|
27. Holy moly! I can't believe it! Rivkah
said something that I can't TOTALLY disagree with! Everybody grab something solid. I think the earth is about to cleave in two!
| Joe , |
Ohio, USA |
|
(11.23.07) |
|
|
28. #25
Either you are about 12 years old or you really are so ultimately thick that you cannot even recognise the constant stream of meaningless drivel that you use to pollute our screens.
Give it a break, luv. You are sooooooooooo boring.
| English guy , |
London |
|
(11.23.07) |
|
|
29. 27,28: You are both invited to skip my tb's
since you both lack the wisdom and understanding to appreciate them. Spare yourself from being bored by information you are not ready for or worthy of.
|
|
30. he will get better treatment in an Israeli prison than he
would have in an Iranian prison which is where the Iranians would have sent him on some pretext if they did not kill him if he went there. There are supercomputers that scan all emails, faxes, and phone calls for certain words for intelligence agencies. How could he not know that?
|
|