Opinion  Sever Plocker
Stalin's Jews
Sever Plocker
פורסם: 21.12.06, 23:35
תגובה לכתבה תגובה לכתבה
הדפיסו את התגובות הדפיסו את התגובות
חזרה לכתבה
לכתבה זו התפרסמו 463 תגובות ב-440 דיונים
271. Jew,Gentile,Arab... we're in this together!
Mr. B. "Max" Phillip ,   St. Kitss, Canada   (29.02.08)
It's so sad to read about Jews killing people. We've suffered enough at the hands of many too! I don't believe G-d wants all his children to behave in such a manner. Isn't "love and service" what the Talmud asks us all to do?
272. calm down please
Edson ,   Brazil   (01.03.08)
please, search for "Kosha Boy" on Youtube and let's "get a life"
273. Stalin's jews
David ,   Canada   (01.03.08)
Plocker is finally educating the non-Semitic jews (most Isralelis). Brave man. Thanks.
274. Jew's Greatest Mass Murderer's in Modern Times
Just Stating ,   USA   (01.03.08)
Aren't these so-called Jews, Kahzars? They converted to Judaism in the 8th Century, and usurped the religion and the race of another group. Just saying.
275. Lots of denial, screeching and gnashing of teeth
Rabbit ,   Australia   (01.03.08)
I see that lots of Jews are denying, and lying about this article. Actually it is all known to us, and more and more people are looking closely at you people since your recent blitzkrieg against Lebanon. The denial isn't helping your cause any more than the shills who descend upon any article which is critical of Israel or Jews in general. All you do is live up to stereotypes by trying. You are not some special or chosen people, you are a people mostly of Eastern uropean origin and most of you have no right to the Middle east at all. You are also a nasty, deceitful people who have been kicked out of about half the world's nations over history and not as you'd like to believe because of your primitive religion. It is the lies, the deceit and the general abuse of position which follows you. Until a few years ago I was as misinformed as many others but have begun to open my eyes. I respect Jews such as Plocker for speaking truth, to the obnoxious and powerful forces which drive the Jewish cause further and further towards a well earned destruction. How long do you fools think before the whole world has had enough of your lies and inhumanity?
276. To 274
Eyes Wide Open ,   Australia   (01.03.08)
Khazars? YES, Not jusrt saying, you have done your research and found the truth. "I know of those who call themselves Jews but are not, for they are liars and are of a synagogue of satan" Rev 3:9 And to everyone else, The truth hurts obviously judging by some comments on here. Dont forget the Jews believe they have a monopoly on Holocaust (TM) and suffering. The suffering will continue until they accept Jesus as their Messiah and bow before the only true god. It is written
277. To Just Stating
Eyes Wide Open ,   Australia   (01.03.08)
The first Jews of Ashkenaz (Germany) did not come from the Land of Israel and did not reach Eastern Europe from Germany, but became Jews in the Khazar Kingdom in the Caucasus. Zand explains the origins of Yiddish culture: it was not a Jewish import from Germany, but the result of the connection between the offspring of the Kuzari and Germans who traveled to the East, some of them as merchants. We find, then, that the members of a variety of peoples and races, blond and black, brown and yellow, became Jews in large numbers. According to Zand, the Zionist need to devise for them a shared ethnicity and historical continuity produced a long series of inventions and fictions, along with an invocation of racist theses. Some were concocted in the minds of those who conceived the Zionist movement, while others were offered as the findings of genetic studies conducted in Israel. Prof. Zand teaches at Tel Aviv University. His book, "When and How Was the Jewish People Invented?" (published by Resling in Hebrew), is intended to promote the idea that Israel should be a "state of all its citizens" - Jews, Arabs and others - in contrast to its declared identity as a "Jewish and democratic" state. Personal stories, a prolonged theoretical discussion and abundant sarcastic quips do not help the book, but its historical chapters are well- written and cite numerous facts and insights that many Israelis will be astonished to read for the first time
278. Postscript to my last post..........
Eyes Wide Open ,   Australia   (01.03.08)
"The world we have created is a product of our thinking; it cannot be changed without changing our thinking." -Albert Einstein-
279. Missing the author's point--USA has same problem
Jingles ,   toronto   (03.03.08)
Matter of fact most of west nations have been infested by the same crazies.Alarm bells are ringing--look at America's Jewish stronghold. No different than Lenin or Stalin's or Hitler's Jewish Hunchmen.Wake-up Israel firsters before the masses wake-up againts all Jews..Very sad-- Jews want to hide history and soon it will come back and bite us all [:-(
280. Bravo YNET!!!
(03.03.08)
Bravo YNET!!!
281. Frankfurt school of philisophy took off after economic comm
Marc Villa ,   Houston, Texas   (03.03.08)
We do not have look far into history to see the cultural demise of Critical Theory's i.e. Political Correctness the West influenced by the Frankfurt School of philosophers mostly Jewish intellectuals, social engineers destruction of the Judeo-Christian values.
282. IT BLOWS MY MIND HOW . . .
HPS ,   USA   (04.03.08)
. . . so many Zionist extremists really BELIEVE their proclomations qualify as genuine arguments. I have an ex "friend" I tried to debate, or at least QUESTION this matter and it was impossible. He had ZERO evidence to support his assertions while I had tons to support my mine. The man was so narcissistic and reactionary that he was incapable of reason. News flash folks: Regardless of our political or religious persuasions, our opinions do not negate facts. Facts are not anti-semitic; rather it's the "spin" that matters. Too many here are accusing this author of antisemitic spin where there is none. Historical perspectives, if they are based on FACT, should be taken on as topics and discussed openly. Freaking out, calling antisemitism and flouncing off in a huff because someone states a plain fact is irrational. It shuts down communication and gets us nowhere. Why do (some) Jews think their race must be "better," or at least more blameless, than non-Jews when it comes to our tragic histories? Why does Jewish tragedy have to be the most tragic of all? Is this the Persecution Olympics? Do you have a Gold Medal to defend? Why should the existence of races and religions that suffered as much or more than Jews - at the hands of Jews - be so upsetting? Do you actually presume the Jewish race is morally superior? If so, might I suggest some therapy?
283. Mr Moderator//Plocker?
Eyes Wide Open ,   Australia   (05.03.08)
Dear Mr Plocker, I notice my last comment has not been posted, this may just be due to the time difference between Israel & Australia or it may have been deemed offensive. If the latter is the case I wished no intent, I do have the sometimes unfortunate tendency to say things exactly as I see it, or as facts dictate with no regard for political correctness. I deal in facts not in malicious intent and offer my apology if that was the impression I gave. I find Ynet and Haaretz to be easily the best publications out of Israel primarily for their ability to broach "taboo" subjects honestly and factually and allow readers to comment with great lattitude for freedom of speech. I congratulate you on your work and your publication, if only more were like you, I truly believe Israel would be a prosperous, free, multicultural and peaceful nation respected in the region and the world. Sincerely Shalom
284. Re We mustn't forget that some of greatest murderers of mode
John Heininger ,   Australia   (07.03.08)
One should never forget that power corrupts, absolute power corrupts absolutely. Be it a secular, Christian or Jewish power. This is true of all races and political powers, which is why most of us prefer to live in a democracy rather than any theocracy or totalitarian state. Fellow secular Jews supported Karl Marx because they had suffered years of hardship and rejection in supposedly 'Christian' Russia, as the movie Fiddler on the Roof incapulates. As an Evangelical Christian who actively supports Israel and the Jewish people I sense a parallel with modern Israel's struggle to survive in yet another hostile environment. Shalom. Shalom.
285. they in power still
katolik ,   Poland   (05.04.08)
because THEY are still in power, building up new society, now they can be found in brussels and washington. but don't be mistaken, they are still the same bad communists
286. Stupid Article?
Parasite ,   US   (06.07.08)
Is it a stupid article because it shows that the "jew" was responsible for the Bolshevik Revolution? People may have forgotten for quite some time the evils the "jew" is guilty of but noone should expect People to remain in a state of amnesia forever! Woe be on the head of every non-Semitic "jew" who claims their ancestors to be from the Holy Land when they are nothing more but imposters! You Anti-Christ satanists deserve what's coming your way.
287. Illuminating History's Darkest Corners!
Joseph ,   London, England   (13.07.08)
Can anyone please tell me where the Holodomor museums are? I want to visit and learn more about history's worst crime against humanity which has been conveniently swept under the rug by a liberal and largely jewish media. Who invented communism anyway?
288. Great Article
Goyim ,   USA   (17.07.08)
Is speaking the truth now considered anti-semitism?
289. Stalin's Jews
shosha ,   Haifa   (17.07.08)
It is time someone addressed this important subject. It is long overdue as is much of our true history and we cannot shirk out past wrongs if we want the rest of mankind to truly know who we are and understand us. Our biggest problem as a people has been and still is denial of wrongs committed by Jews against others while at the same time constantly complaining over and over again about the wrongs committed against us while committing wrongs against others on a daily basis. Thankyou for this important article. It is time to make Jews think about what they are doing to themselves with our constant denials regarding everything we do (it seems we cannot even admit to a minor mistake and this is a sad, sad commentary on the modern day Jewish People and moreover on the state of the State of Israel and what it is doing to the young people of our country. They leave high school and university completely ignorant of the true history of the Jewish People and this is truly unacceptable.
290. history
Paul ,   Australia   (18.07.08)
I don't think history reveals any race, nation, or religion as spotless. Some are just more sensitive about being told about it. If Jewish people don't know their true history its no wonder they so clearly haven't learnt from it.
291. Coming soon to the USA
escapefrombushistan ,   Dallas, TX   (18.07.08)
compliments of Comrade Michael Chertoff and "Homeland" Security.
292. Very good article - and overdue
sharpinchitown ,   Chicago, Illinois   (18.07.08)
Spectacular article that approaches a topic much avoided in today's world. Until we face all of the past's tragic events and periods in history, at the hands of yes, even the Jews, we WILL repeat them again and again. Today, the same thing is happening under the guise of Zionism (yet the founders and most others aren't even religious Jews). We must not allow the atheist internationalist Zionists to destroy all that we have worked to preserve, which is freedom, liberty and independence; in other words democracy. They are using the loopholes in capitalism to prove it is a failed system to promote their own goals of international communism. We know what goal but we must stop it because we can't have a repeat of a world under someone like Stalin, especially not using the defense of the Holocaust, for many understand that those who initially created Israel were the children of those who caused the Bolshevik revolution.
293. #20 Sarit
sharpinchitown ,   Chicago, Illinois   (18.07.08)
The rightist Jews are doing the same thing now as the leftist Jews did then; in fact, capitalism as it is currently expressed, is identical to (corporate) communism. This will deliberately lead to the fall of free markets (which are anything but free) and the rise of state run industry - happening already in the US with the Feds taking over banks, just like the internationalists always wanted. Worldwide communism is not the answer and if you can't see how the hand that guides recent history (take China's rise to power as an example) is communist then there's no hope for a good future for anyone. It is very sad that nobody on these boards is capable of seeing how their ancestry could do wrong. Utterly disappointing that you're not able to see the truth. I guess we just continue to repeat history then.
294. #57 Roger
sharpinchitown ,   chicago, Illinois   (18.07.08)
Ashkenazis weren't Jewish either - they ADOPTED the religion. So what the hell's the difference here? There is no clarity in being Jewish anymore. None whatsoever. Is it a religion? is it a bloodline? if yes to both, where do 85% of the world's Jews who come from Ashkenazi roots stand, especially since you can't "choose" Judaism, according to the tenets of the religion? By your definition of what a Jew is, very few Jews are then, by definition, Jewish, because they have not lived in Judea for thousands of years and therefore were raised in their respective host lands with their food, mentality, culture, literature, ideologies, history and lands. So Roger, which is it? Is someone Jewish regardless of where they live or aren't they?
295. Unbelievable
Tony ,   Dallas, US   (18.07.08)
HOW is this article anti-semitic? I wonder if those who characterize as such are as horrified by Israel and the ADL not even recognizing the Armenian holocaust. The basic tenet of the article is this. If you're gonna observe other people's glass houses, be candid about your own. Calling this article anti-semitic is nothing more or less than calling evil good and calling good evil. And if you do so while professing to represent Judaism as a religion and as a moral imperative, your obeisance is to a false and evil God that merely mirrors your own immorality - and perhaps justifies it. Tony
296. It's true and yet....
Miriam ,   Sydney   (19.07.08)
many Jews were also persecuted by Stalin's apparatchiks. Many of the Jews who joined the Communist party hated their religion, all religions, and really thought that they were making the world a better place by getting rid of it. If your people had suffered centuries of religiously incited pogroms, you can see how they would think like this. However, like any cause where the believers think they have all the answers, they get carried away with it ( such as with the 'War on Terror') and the most despicable among them turn it into an opportunity for theft and thuggery. Judaism is not to blame for these aberrations - rather those who follow the motto 'Ordo ab Chao' and believe that the ends always justifies the means. These followers are to be found among the practitioners of every religion and they sincerely believe that they have a divine right to constantly pillage, rape and steal from the 'profane' - that is, those who do not form part of this elite.
297. Stalin's Jews
Allan Stein ,   United States   (19.07.08)
No one's ethnicity places them above the laws of God and humanity. May the Soviet Union rest in peace.
298. First You Deny it, Then you Insult, then You Excuse it
The Voice ,   Miami, USA   (19.07.08)
To #97 and Others When confronted with the truth, your first reaction is to deny it, then when you start to realize it is true, you insult others, and then you Excuse it. To those that have bad mouthed the Pentecostal Christians and other Christians, I just want to let you know that they foolishly support with their money the State of Israel and just like you, they have also been deceived. Our President has surrounded himself with people by the name of Wolfowitz, Bernanke, Chertoff, Perle, etc. They hold the most high-ranking, strategic positions in government and they are implementing their One World Government aka Communism policy. The vast majority of Americans don't know what's going on. They are being deceived just like you guys were.
299. First admission - finally!
Karl ,   Rome, Italy   (17.09.08)
Excellent and very brave article. A jewish Khazar admits to one of the many genocides the jewish Khazars (aka the Ashkenazim) organized at the expense of other nations. It remains to admit to that of the Armenians, of the Germans after WW1 and WW2 (9 ML civilian victims) and many more, yes of the Palestinians and now the Irakis as well. This is no hate judgement: it is based on solid knowledge of the Jews' real, hidden history (not the official history). You can believe the jewish Khazars did what this article says they did to the Ukrainians. Why? Because the Ukrainians, descendents of the Kievian Rus', and their host jewish Khazars have always locked horns with each other since the Rus' brought down Greater Khazaria in 965 AD. The 1917 'russian' Revolution was in fact the restauration under Communism's banner of the Golden Horde (Kipchak Khaganate) which followed the Mongols' invasion and brought Russia under the central asian's heal. The Ashkenazis and the other asian nations within Russia took control of the Politburo, the Cheka, NKVD and all other soviet powerhouses. And so they organised their revenge on the Rus'. Most or all of Stalin's Thousanders in the Holodmor were central asians: Ashkenazis, Tatars, you name it. The aim was to recapture some of Greater Khazaria's lands, including the Crimea (aka Little Khazaria). Another reason for the Holodmor was the 'modernization' of soviet agriculture. Namely, disposing of the peasants and their horses (9 ML were left to starve to death) and replacing them with tractors and combines ... imported from the USA. In other words: opening a new market for the brother businessmen (Karp for example, brother in law of Molotov) already emigrated to the USA. Atavic racial hatred plus expanding markets were the reasons behind this forgotten tragedy.
300. Sever Plocker is a honorable person
Schmidt David ,   Canada   (07.11.08)
The fact that a a jewish admitted the jewish involvment in the red terror makes me to respect him and to adjust my opinion the the jewish couldn't cry for any other victims than themselves. This article doesn't fuel the antisemitism as ones could infer. On the contrary, assuming our past mistakes is the ultimate weapon of preventing repeating them. The truth will set us free !
תגובות קודמות
תגובות נוספות
חזרה לכתבה